Assalamualaikum pretty ladies!
I think we all have a penchant for black eyeliners, I hardly have a pencil liner as I prefer retractable eyeliners, so far I've bought another Silkygirl retractable gel liner which has awesome pigmentation but low lasting power, but I'll try to get on the reviews with that soon, InshaAllah.
I bought this for RM11+, very affordable as I think it was on sale, I was trying to actually find a replacement for my Essence's black longlasting pencil, which is very impossible, as nothing can beat the performance of that particular black pencil.
I have a fondness for retractable pencils, as I don't really like the normal pencils that needs sharpening, which explains why most of my pencils that needs sharpening isn't being loved and used by me, so definitely won't buy any of that.
The colors are acceptably pigmented, the texture is creamy and dries to a semi-matte finish, I've tried using this on my waterline, tightlining and on my lash line. It doesn't last long on my waterline, at least for 2-3 hours? I haven't tried setting it with a black eyeshadow, but nevertheless, my eyes are watery, so I think its rather useless, however it does stay unmoved over my lash line, using it to create a cat eye line.
Although, if you didn't set it with eyeshadow, it would definitely smudge onto your undereyes. A fairly acceptable product that I might not ever repurchase.